How can there be such abuse in religious orders and is there a place for single Catholics?    
Bringing you the "Good News" of Jesus Christ and His Church While PROMOTING CATHOLIC Apologetic Support groups loyal to the Holy Father and Church's magisterium
Home About
AskACatholic.com
What's New? Resources The Church Family Life Mass and
Adoration
Ask A Catholic
Knowledge base
AskACatholic Disclaimer
Search the
AskACatholic Database
Donate and
Support our work
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
New Questions
Cool Catholic Videos
About Saints
Disciplines and Practices for distinct Church seasons
Purgatory and Indulgences
About the Holy Mass
About Mary
Searching and Confused
back
Contemplating becoming a Catholic or Coming home
Homosexual and Gender Issues
Life, Dating, and Family
No Salvation Outside the Church
Sacred Scripture
non-Catholic Cults
Justification and Salvation
The Pope and Papacy
The Sacraments
Relationships and Marriage situations
Specific people, organizations and events
Doctrine and Teachings
Specific Practices
Church Internals
Church History


Rejected Rosemary wrote:

Hi, guys —

I am a Catholic convert of 4 years with no Catholic family. Right after I was confirmed, I was set loose into the Catholic Church with no guidance whatsoever on how to connect with other Catholics. I tried to fit in my parish of 3,000 members by playing violin in the guitar-singing group for the Masses.

After 3 years of that, I realized that no matter what I gave to the Church, or how I tried to participate, without any Catholic family, there was no way to ever fit into the Catholic Church as a single person. The parish music group had no problem using me as a professional violinist in their group, but I noticed that outside of rehearsals and Masses, none of the group's members cared to even speak to me. I saw an entry on a web site for former Catholics from a man who had served his parish music program for 12 years and still felt like no one cared about him because he was single so I wondered what hope there would be for me. I found it impossible to make friends in the Church for this reason.

One lady in the group pretended to befriend me, and then gossiped about everything I shared with her. Also, because of her enormous family, there was never any time that she could get together with me even to talk. My only family is:

  • an elderly mother, a United Methodist, who disapproves of my beliefs as a Catholic
  • an atheist turned Alzheimer's patient father, and
  • a fire and brimstone Seventh Day Adventist Preacher brother who tells me I am going straight to hell for converting to Catholicism and who never speaks to me.

I entered RCIA because I went to a Catholic college where a Catholic professor impressed me so much with his compassion, and because I was so abused in the United Methodist Church by judgmental, slanderous, hateful, vengeful behavior from everyone from Pastors down to the members. As time went on, and I studied more about the faith in a (LPMP) Lay Pastoral Ministry program sponsored by my Archdiocese. I came to truly appreciate the teachings of the Catholic Church and how beautiful they are. Since then, I have been searching in vain to find even one Catholic who really lives these teachings.

For many years before I even became Catholic, I felt called to serve God in some collaborative way with others, and there were various joking hints along the way by people who recognized my call that I would make a great nun.

Because my parents were elderly and I needed to be in the same city with them, I inquired with the wrong order of religious sisters, an order that is dying rapidly because it no longer lives its mission statement and just spends its remaining days partying in gluttony and drunkenness.
The order took full advantage of me as a musician, and didn't even pay me for my services. Before I even moved in, I heard comments suggesting the women in that house did not want any more candidates. As soon as I moved into their "five-sister" convent, it was as if I became public enemy number one and they treated me in the most un-Christian, most abusive, merciless manner you can imagine, even to the point of denying me the right to any heat in my room the entire winter.

When it got to the point that my health was in danger and they realized that they were literally killing me, then they suddenly terminated me from the order also in the cruelest fashion you can imagine. They also went out of their way to slander me throughout the city and archdiocese so that they would look good and I would look bad. They also refused to give me a good recommendation for all the good work I did while in their convent, and basically trashed me as a human being. Now that I have been chewed up and spit out from a religious order, I understand why they are dying out.

There appears to be huge dysfunctional families in which severe abuse has been passed down the generations. It may be true that they did good work to help many people in the past, but none of that justifies completely destroying a person's life just because she wanted to serve God with them. This order's mission statement has to do with reconciliation and being a life-giving presence to the world. I have never felt so alienated in my entire life as when I tried to associate with them.

Currently, my health is in jeopardy because of the abuse I suffered this past year and I remain without any support from my own parish or priest. As for my Lay Pastoral Ministry project,
I offered to start a free volunteer violin program in my parish school. My priest wanted me to
do this until he heard something bad about me (more slander and negative gossip). After this,
he went out and hired another violin teacher to do that job, even though it was my idea and my project. For this reason, I was unable to graduate from the LPMP program.

So far two Catholic doctors have refused to even allow me to be treated in their clinics and recently, my parent's neighbors, a pious Catholic couple from my parish, harassed my poor, elderly, worn-out mom because her gutters were leaking in their yard and they wanted a huge profit on the sale of their home. One of the sisters in the convent where I lived this year influenced my spiritual director to terminate all contact with me which they both have done right before my birthday and the holidays, knowing as they do, that I have no one to talk to anymore.

At the present time, I am struggling to keep my faith alive in a vacuum of total alienation and isolation. The only Catholics I have any contact with are all people who lost their faith and left the Church a long time ago because of past abuse and unfriendly behavior by people in parishes.

I realize now that I could continue receiving the Eucharist and find Christ's love in that, but sooner or later, if I never see any true manifestation of that love anywhere in the Catholic Church, even among so-called religious people, I may not be able to keep the faith. I do not wish to go on living in pain and being unable to forgive but, in my entire life of 52 years, I have never seen any evidence that reconciliation is ever possible in the human race.

My questions are:

  • How can Christ be in any of the abuses of the Catholic Religious orders?
  • Is there any place for singles to find support in the Catholic Church?
  • How can I keep my faith under these circumstances in total isolation?
  • Where can I go to find a Catholic friend who really lives the teachings of the Church and who would have time for a single person?
  • Is there any support group for rejects of religious orders?

Sincerely yours,

Rejected Rosemary

  { How can there be such abuse in religious orders and is there a place for single Catholics? }

Mary Ann replied:

Dear Rejected,

First, I am sorry for all that you have suffered. It is unjust.

Second, Christ is not in any of the abuses that you suffered. He is in you, however, suffering these abuses with you.

Third, your faith is in God and in the Catholic Church, not in:

  • your parish
  • those people, or
  • in that order.

Many people in the Catholic Church have lost the faith and live in a worldly manner.

Fourth, this is a good question, because you have not had good luck finding good Catholic friends. I find your situation to be extreme and unusual. I know there are good single Catholics, and friendly ones. I wouldn't look to parish activities to find them, though, because they are not greatly in evidence there.

For friendship, I would simply do the things that you are passionate about doing, whether it is music or something else, and you will meet people who share your interests. You can, of course, be friends with people who are not Catholic too. Also, there is no reason that you can't write a letter or schedule an appointment with the pastor in order to clarify any false things he may have heard about you.

Finally, you are not a reject. You should thank God you are out of the order and pray to be led to a better one, if that is your vocation. Ask the Lord to send you some good Catholic friends.

Welcome to the club of those who suffer for Christ and with Christ. We should always be humble enough to look at our failings and see how they may be impacting our situations. Meanwhile, trust God, put not your trust in the children of men, Psalm 146:3-5 and find a good place to go to daily Mass and Adoration.

Mary Ann

Mike replied:

Hi, Rosemary —

Let me add a bit on to Mary Ann's solid remarks.

It appears you have been through a lot, yet out of every bad thing that happens in our life, God can, and does, put out a greater good. If you haven't already, I would focus on a daily prayer life. My preference is the Holy Rosary. I can send you a free one if you wish or you can easily obtain one on-line. If you already are saying the Rosary, I think the key is petitioning the Lord and perseverance.

Ask the Lord to send priests into your life who are holy priests as well as Catholics that just enjoy being Catholic. I enjoy being Catholic and I think everyone should enjoy being Catholic. We have nothing to be ashamed of ...

Well? Almost nothing :) Yes, we have sinners in our Church too and some of them are big timers.

What's key is focusing on the Truth the Church contains and safeguards. You don't want to:

Leave Peter because of Judas behavior.

I don't know anything about your current spiritual director, but if he doesn't:

  • have a strong devotion to Our Blessed Mother
  • have a strong devotion to the Blessed Sacrament and
  • is not faithful to the teachings of the Holy Father

I would find another spiritual director. If you can't find another, ask that the Lord in prayer to send one to you.

Know that I will keep all your non-Catholic family members in my prayers. I will pray for a complete conversion to the Catholic faith for each of your family members ... and

Yes, that includes you brimstone Seventh Day Adventist Preacher brother :) If he is confident about his faith, he should have no problems stopping by our site and searching our database for answers or asking us some questions.

No matter what the question, I believe we are very charitable.

Finally note: Try our COCFF'r Close Orthodox Catholic Friend Finder on the home page.

Hope this helps,

Mike

Bob replied:

Dear Rejected,

Your story is sad and pitiable, but there is always hope. While finding deeper relationships within certain church communities and parishes is often difficult and frustrating, it is not impossible.

I have many single friends that have flourished and continue to do so. In our diocese of Boston, there are many social groups for Catholics, and singles in particular; you should check with your own diocese to see what exists. Perhaps seeking a connection in a roundabout way — helping in Pro-Life activities, St. Vincent De Paul, etc. may be the thing. Many people have attended retreats such as Cursillo and found thriving communities through the networks created by those who have attended.

I will try to handle my last thought in a most sensitive way.

So much of your letter has a tone of one who truly feels almost persecuted. I am concerned that part of your difficulty forging friendships has to do with trust issues and other feelings that may be echoes of your past.

I don't know you personally so I cannot speak from direct knowledge, but I sense that some personal counseling would be beneficial to you. Perhaps there is some breakthrough ahead in your own journey that will help you to develop stronger skills in navigating the area of relationships (with both singles and married couples) that could enhance your fellowship opportunities.

I will certainly pray that God leads you to discern the best way for you to break free from your isolation and loneliness.

God bless,

Bob K.

Help us spread the Catholic Gospel. Please link to us and,
if you have the means, financially support our work!
Please report any and all typos or grammatical errors.
Suggestions for this web page and the web site can be sent to Mike Humphrey
© 2012 Panoramic Sites
The Early Church Fathers Church Fathers on the Primacy of Peter. The Early Church Fathers on the Catholic Church and the term Catholic. The Early Church Fathers on the importance of the Roman Catholic Church centered in Rome.